Page ID: 04.01.00

 

Comparison

Whilst there are alternative products which nominally compete in this field, their properties are substantially different from one another. This means that for most applications they are not competitors at all as specific properties are likely to make one or other technology either particularly appropriate or unsuitable for a particular use.

The table below sets out the principal alternative technologies and their properties, the main differentiating features are:

Environmentally Degradable Polymer Pros Cons Application
Polyolefins plus pro-degradant additive
Oxo-biodegradables (PE and PP with low levels of pro-degradant additive)
Includes d2w technology
  • Very low price
  • Maintains all plastic properties
  • Good barrier properties
  • Degrades as litter
  • Easy processing
Slow in domestic compost
  • Packaging - esp. sacks, bags and food
  • Films esp. wraps
  • Disposables
Naturally occurring polymers
Pure Starch and blends of starch and LDPE (potato, corn etc)
  • Low price
  • Good compostability
  • Renewable
  • Low strength
  • Water soluble
  • Poor processability
  • Poor clarity
  • Recycling not possible
  • Packaging
  • Compost sacks
  • Loose fill
Synthetic aliphatic polyesters
PCL's (Polycaprolactones incl. modified starch blends)
  • Good compostability
  • Biocompatible
  • High price
  • Low strength
  • Poor barrier properties
  • Recycling not possible
  • Compost bags
  • Adhesive
  • Bottles
  • Film
PHA's, including PHB and PHBV (Polyhydroalkanoates)
  • Good compostability
  • Biocompatible
  • Renewable
  • Bad smell
  • High price
  • Poor processability
  • Recycling not possible
  • Food packaging
  • Bottles
  • Medical
PLA (Polylactic acid)
  • Transparency
  • Strength
  • Stability
  • Biocompatible
  • High price
  • Poor processability
  • Brittleness
  • Poor flexibility
  • Recycling not possible
  • Food packaging
  • Bottles
  • Medical
Other synthetic Environmentally Degradable Polymers
PVA (Polyvinylalcohol)
  • Good compostability
  • Clarity
  • Water soluble
  • High price
  • Difficult processability
  • Recycling not possible
  • Water solubles
  • Personal hygiene prods
  • Disposables